Sunday, March 1, 2015

Perspective

I used to have these wonderful dreams of kind of mother I'd be (I guess most of us have), but in all those dreams, my kids were perfect, and I never had to deal with misbehavior...in that kind of world, it's easy to be the perfect mom! When Finn grew out of the baby phase and I did have to deal with misbehavior, I realized that the parenting style I grew up with didn't fit me well.  Which led to lots of reading and research on my part as I tried to find what works for me, and that led me to the concept that discipline is about teaching the proper way to behave, not punishing for misbehavior (note, that's not to say there won't be consequences for misbehavior but natural consequences are different than punishments).  I've been holding back from fully embracing this because I wondered what people would think when they saw this in action.  I wondered and I worried that I would be judged.

Over the several months, I've also realized that much of my interactions with both boys is tinged with some constant background noise: am I doing the right thing? am I doing the right thing in the right way? what will other people think of my parenting choices? am I damaging my children? am I making it worse?  The list goes on and on.

It's exhausting, all this worry about other people and about doing things the "right way." It puts distance between me and my boys, keeping me from being in the moment. And it keeps me from trusting in my own instincts.

So these thoughts have been percolating in the back of my mind over the past few months - and then I found myself in a parenting situation with Finn that had quickly deteriorated to the point that he was not thinking at all, not hearing what I was saying, and lashing out by trying to hurt me.  There have been several times this has happened where I have been tempted to laugh at the ridiculousness of it, but stopped myself because "that's not how it's done." But this time, I felt the urge to laugh, so I ignored everything but my instincts and I laughed.

And what do you know - Finn stopped, looked at me with surprise, and then started laughing, too.  Just like that, the horrible moment passed, all bad feelings were lost in the laughter, and he said, "I'm sorry, mommy," gave me a hug, and did what I'd asked him to do.  Later he misbehaved a little and I could see him looking to me to see how I would react and when I reacted with humor, he relaxed and grinned at me.

Wow.  I listened to my instincts instead of over-thinking the situation, and it worked.

Somehow, that's given me the freedom to finally stop worrying so much about the rules and about everyone else and focus on what's right for our family.  I'll take a little that I learned from this book, and little that I learned from that blog, and blend it into something that works.  And whenever we hit a new phase that I struggle with, I'll go back to the books, try something new. And when all else fails, I'll just laugh.

Because sometimes, that's all it takes to make everything better.


14 comments:

  1. That sounds like sound advice...from yourself. Xoxo

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing that. We struggle sometimes with how to avoid the power struggles (especially when *I'm* tired and cranky), so it's good to know that humor works at least some of the time. I hope it keeps working for you!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I also subscribe to the idea that discipline is about teaching the child the right behavior/getting the bad behavior to stop, not about punishing. I do frequently feel judged for not being strict enough, but I also frequently get complimented for having well-behaved kids. So...

    It's hard to ignore the judgment, though.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great idea - give yourself a break and a pat on the back. It's a hard job and he so like you are shaping him to be a wonderful human being! Kudos for reflecting, trying new things and always wanting the best for your children!

    ReplyDelete
  5. This parenting thing is tough!! I fight this same urge of worrying about what other people think, especially around my family. But I find when it is just Elsie and I behind closed doors, things are much better and I wonder if it is because I "give in" too much (which is what my family accuses me of) or if I am more relaxed so we both don't escalate. I have a feeling ti is a bit of both. :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. I also try to avoid the authoritarian way I was parented and go more with positive discipline techniques. But I think even that philosophy is much too big on "this is THE right way to parent." (Just as I felt about attachment parenting with infants - wonderful philosophy, but too dogmatic). There are so many effective ways to parent and to build a strong bond. It's just as ridiculous to expect ourselves to be perfect all the time as it is to expect that of our kids.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "I'll take a little that I learned from this book, and little that I learned from that blog, and blend it into something that works." THIS!! Yes, yes, yes!! I really gained my parenting confidence when I started to do this, cherry pick the theories & techniques & keep the ones that work for us. I had a hard time at first because if something didn't work for us I would get really down on myself thinking I was failing or doing something wrong. That's a lot of pressure. You are so right about having a good laugh too! If I'm more relaxed then E is way more compliant & laid back too! So happy for you for finding your groove!

    ReplyDelete
  8. The way I look at it with my two boys: Pushing mommy over the edge, so that she becomes visibly angry and maybe even screams at you, is a natural consequence, too! Laughing is probably better and it is also a natural reaction, since much behavior is simply ridiculous.

    I do not scream at them in any regular interval, it happened rarely and I explained and apologized after it to. It is not a good behavior at any age. However, reacting in a real way by allowing yourself to show feelings, too - I find that important. If one of my children hurts his brother intentionally Mom will become visibly upset.

    I do not think of it as a "parenting technique", that is an unusual word and I think only in this country people read books about this. It is an interaction between several people in a family. Reacting in a way you feel about a situation is teaching them to consider other people's feelings and that is the most important thing to learn of all.

    This is asking a lot of a toddler, but the older they get, the more important this is, I think.

    ReplyDelete
  9. There is just not "right" way to parent/discipline because every child is different. What worked one time for Sidekick, doesn't always work the next time. That's what makes being a Mom hard. I don't read books about discipline because right now, Sidekick is doing well with what I do with him. I do ask other parents what they did about certain things and take it all with a grain of salt. I'm not into the sticker chart, but it works for many, and timeout on the stairs works for him (and he usually puts himself in time out). Sidekick is a pleaser, so I'm fortunate that he usually wants to make the right choices and do the right things. However, as we are approaching three, I'm seeing little bit of the devil in him. : )

    ReplyDelete
  10. I love this post and your reflections and growing awareness of what works for you and the boys. Also I admire your pursuit of knowledge with books and reaching out to ask people - that's so awesome and something a lot of people might not do for whatever reason. Yay, for allowing natural reactions. I'm sure I will try and find these posts if/when I become a mom. Sending kudos and good thoughts.

    ReplyDelete
  11. You pinpointed it exactly - we are often worried about what others will think of our parenting styles. Parenting is hard! I get a lot of judgement for the cosleeping and nursing through the night at 20 months....but it works for us. As for my 4 year old, laughing at the situation doesn't work with us - she feels insulted....but it works for you so go for it. The parenting experts are "right" if they aren't parents of our children. :) Great post.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'm not sure my last comment went through, it was kinda long so I won't re-type it, but I'll just say again I think you're doing amazing and I love when we follow our guts as mamas.

    ReplyDelete